Expensive Hockey Cards of the Post-War Era

Hockey card collecting has been a favorite hobby of many for the past 100 years or so and the collectors are serious about their cards. Rarer cards can be worth a great deal of money, well into the thousands. There are some very expensive hockey cards on the market and the high price tag does nothing to dissuade collectors from pursuing them. So what are the most valuable, expensive hockey cards of all time? Below is a list of the top five modern era hockey cards starting with the holy grail:

  • Wayne Gretzky O-Pee-Chee #18 rookie card – The card for any serious collection. It shows a young Gretzky in action in his Edmonton Oilers jersey and has been sold for as much as $94,000 in perfect condition. This is the ultimate in expensive hockey cards and is the one every hockey fan longs to own.
  • Bobby Orr 1966-67 Topps #35 rookie card – Many people consider Bobby Orr to be serious competition for Gretzky as the greatest hockey player of all time and his 1966 issue rookie card shows this in its value. Although it has never sold for the record-breaking price of Gretzky’s rookie card, the Orr rookie card value can be as high as $50,000 when graded mint by an authenticator, making it a close second in the list of most desirable and expensive hockey cards.
  • Gordie Howe 1951-52 Parkhurst #66 rookie card – Gretzky’s idol and one of the greats, Gordie Howe was known as Mr. Hockey. This rookie card is exceedingly rare because of the very thin paper stock used for printing Parkhurst cards. It is believed that not many of these treasures remain in mint condition. As such, its value of almost $18,000 for a high grade example is no surprise.
  • Mario Lemieux ‘85 Topps #9 rookie card – Mario Lemieux was one of the greatest and most diverse scorers in the history of hockey and one of only three players to resume the game after being inducted into the Hall of Fame. This card can vary wildly because of condition, but gem mint 10 copies can run well into the thousands.  Those with even minor wear usually bring much, much less.
  • Gordie Howe ‘54 Topps #8 – The only card in the top five that is not a rookie card and the 2nd card in this list that features Howe. This card issue was more mainstream and higher quality than the Parkhurst card so it is a great addition to any hockey card collection. At a value of around $13,000 for a high grade example, it is definitely deserving of its spot on the list of most expensive hockey cards of all time.

Of course, scarce cards from the pre-World War II era can also attract bidders with deep pockets because of their scarcity, but grading services have upped the ante, even on modern era cards as collectors of expensive hockey cards want only the best of the best.

1991 Upper Deck Sergei Fedorov Red Wings 6 Rookie PSA 10 26225377 HOF 2015
1991 Upper Deck Sergei Fedorov Red Wings 6 Rookie PSA 10 26225377 HOF 2015
$65.00
Time Remaining: 14d 4h 6m
Buy It Now for only: $65.00
1969 O Pee Chee 138 Tony Esposito RC Rookie PSA 9 Blackhawks 1969 70 OPC HOF
1969 O Pee Chee 138 Tony Esposito RC Rookie PSA 9 Blackhawks 1969 70 OPC HOF
$699.99
Time Remaining: 5d 17h 45m
Buy It Now for only: $699.99
1984 Topps Hockey 49 Steve Yzerman HOF Detroit Red Wings RC Rookie PSA 9 MINT 2
1984 Topps Hockey 49 Steve Yzerman HOF Detroit Red Wings RC Rookie PSA 9 MINT 2
$41.99
Time Remaining: 29d 14h 4m
Buy It Now for only: $41.99
1985 O Pee Chee 9 Mario Lemieux HOF rookie PSA 8 very nice Penguins
1985 O Pee Chee 9 Mario Lemieux HOF rookie PSA 8 very nice Penguins
$324.99
Time Remaining: 13d 9h 56m
Buy It Now for only: $324.99
1992 Topps Pavel Bure Canucks 8 Rookie PSA 10 24654913 HOF 2012 POP 4
1992 Topps Pavel Bure Canucks 8 Rookie PSA 10 24654913 HOF 2012 POP 4
$65.00
Time Remaining: 21d 35m
Buy It Now for only: $65.00
1985 O PEE CHEE OPC HOCKEY 9 MARIO LEMIEUX ROOKIE PSA 9 MINT PENGUINS HOF 4249
1985 O PEE CHEE OPC HOCKEY 9 MARIO LEMIEUX ROOKIE PSA 9 MINT PENGUINS HOF 4249
$1,179.99
Time Remaining: 21d 13h 2m
Buy It Now for only: $1,179.99
1980 Topps Hockey 67 Michel Goulet HOF Quebec Nordiques RC Rookie PSA 9 MINT
1980 Topps Hockey 67 Michel Goulet HOF Quebec Nordiques RC Rookie PSA 9 MINT
$0.99
Time Remaining: 6d 18h 58m
1984 O Pee Chee OPC 67 Steve Yzerman Rookie PSA 10 Gem Mint HOF Red Wings
1984 O Pee Chee OPC 67 Steve Yzerman Rookie PSA 10 Gem Mint HOF Red Wings
$1,098.88
Time Remaining: 17d 17h 7m
Buy It Now for only: $1,098.88
1991 Arena Holograms Peter Forsberg Flyers 4 Rookie PSA 10 26225380 HOF 2014
1991 Arena Holograms Peter Forsberg Flyers 4 Rookie PSA 10 26225380 HOF 2014
$50.00
Time Remaining: 14d 4h 5m
Buy It Now for only: $50.00
1968 69 O PEE CHEE BERNIE PARENT ROOKIE PSA 7 HOF PHILADELPHIA FLYERS
1968 69 O PEE CHEE BERNIE PARENT ROOKIE PSA 7 HOF PHILADELPHIA FLYERS
$1,250.00
Time Remaining: 28d 10h 32m
Buy It Now for only: $1,250.00
1991 Upper Deck Sergei Fedorov Red Wings 82 Rookie PSA 9 26296758 HOF 2015
1991 Upper Deck Sergei Fedorov Red Wings 82 Rookie PSA 9 26296758 HOF 2015
$16.00
Time Remaining: 21d 35m
Buy It Now for only: $16.00
1990 Score Eric Lindros Flyers 440 Rookie PSA 9 26225405 HOF 2016 POP 1229
1990 Score Eric Lindros Flyers 440 Rookie PSA 9 26225405 HOF 2016 POP 1229
$16.00
Time Remaining: 21d 34m
Buy It Now for only: $16.00
1990 Score Canadian Mats Sundin Nordiques 398 Rookie PSA10 26520581 HOF 2012
1990 Score Canadian Mats Sundin Nordiques 398 Rookie PSA10 26520581 HOF 2012
$50.00
Time Remaining: 22d 23h 6m
Buy It Now for only: $50.00
1991 Ultimate Draft Peter Forsberg Flyers 61 Rookie PSA 9 26225381 HOF 2014
1991 Ultimate Draft Peter Forsberg Flyers 61 Rookie PSA 9 26225381 HOF 2014
$16.00
Time Remaining: 21d 35m
Buy It Now for only: $16.00
1978 O Pee Chee OPC Hockey 115 Mike Bossy HOF Islanders RC Rookie PSA 75 NM+
1978 O Pee Chee OPC Hockey 115 Mike Bossy HOF Islanders RC Rookie PSA 75 NM+
$0.99
Time Remaining: 6d 18h 58m
1982 O Pee Chee OPC Hockey 105 Grant Fuhr HOF Oilers RC Rookie PSA 10 GEM MINT
1982 O Pee Chee OPC Hockey 105 Grant Fuhr HOF Oilers RC Rookie PSA 10 GEM MINT
$1.25 (2 Bids)
Time Remaining: 6d 18h 57m
1990 Score Canadian Sergei Makarov Flames 329 Rookie PSA 9 26520582 HOF 2016
1990 Score Canadian Sergei Makarov Flames 329 Rookie PSA 9 26520582 HOF 2016
$16.00
Time Remaining: 21d 34m
Buy It Now for only: $16.00
1991 Score Superstars Mike Modano North Stars 35 Rookie PSA 926440010 HOF 2014
1991 Score Superstars Mike Modano North Stars 35 Rookie PSA 926440010 HOF 2014
$16.00
Time Remaining: 21d 35m
Buy It Now for only: $16.00
1990 Score Canadian Eric Lindros Flyers 440 Rookie PSA 9 26520563 HOF 2016
1990 Score Canadian Eric Lindros Flyers 440 Rookie PSA 9 26520563 HOF 2016
$16.00
Time Remaining: 21d 34m
Buy It Now for only: $16.00
1990 Score Canadien Rob Blake Kings 421 Rookie PSA 9 26520577 HOF 2014
1990 Score Canadien Rob Blake Kings 421 Rookie PSA 9 26520577 HOF 2014
$16.00
Time Remaining: 21d 34m
Buy It Now for only: $16.00
1933 34 O PEE CHEE 6 NELS STEWART Rookie PSA Graded 4 VG EX Series A HOF Orange
1933 34 O PEE CHEE 6 NELS STEWART Rookie PSA Graded 4 VG EX Series A HOF Orange
$299.99
Time Remaining: 3d 17h 43m
1986 O Pee Chee OPC Hockey 53 Patrick Roy HOF Canadiens RC Rookie PSA 9 MINT
1986 O Pee Chee OPC Hockey 53 Patrick Roy HOF Canadiens RC Rookie PSA 9 MINT
$499.99
Time Remaining: 14d 12h 48m
Buy It Now for only: $499.99
1971 O Pee Chee OPC Hockey 133 Marcel Dionne HOF Red Wings RC Rookie PSA 9 MINT
1971 O Pee Chee OPC Hockey 133 Marcel Dionne HOF Red Wings RC Rookie PSA 9 MINT
$0.99 (1 Bid)
Time Remaining: 6d 18h 58m
1951 52 Parkhurst 104 Chuck Rayner HOF Rookie PSA 7 New York Rangers
1951 52 Parkhurst 104 Chuck Rayner HOF Rookie PSA 7 New York Rangers
$275.00
Time Remaining: 3d 17h 34m
Buy It Now for only: $275.00
1985 O PEE CHEE OPC HOCKEY 9 MARIO LEMIEUX ROOKIE PSA 9 MINT PENGUINS HOF 3325
1985 O PEE CHEE OPC HOCKEY 9 MARIO LEMIEUX ROOKIE PSA 9 MINT PENGUINS HOF 3325
$1,179.99
Time Remaining: 21d 13h 2m
Buy It Now for only: $1,179.99
1990 Score Canadian Mats Sundin Nordiques 398 Rookie PSA 9 26520579 HOF 2012
1990 Score Canadian Mats Sundin Nordiques 398 Rookie PSA 9 26520579 HOF 2012
$16.00
Time Remaining: 21d 34m
Buy It Now for only: $16.00